🌱 12 Common Community Gardening Challenges & Fixes (2026)

Ever stared at a patch of weeds and wondered, “Did I just sign up for a lifetime of back-breaking labor?” You aren’t alone. At Community Gardening™, we’ve seen the spark of excitement in new gardeners dim the moment a squash vine borer strikes or a late frost nips their seedlings. But here’s the secret the pros don’t always shout from the rooftops: failure is just data. Whether you’re battling the “rental dilemma,” trying to squeeze a harvest into a 4×4 plot, or wrestling with the elusive pepper seed that refuses to sprout, every hurdle has a solution. In this guide, we’re diving deep into the 12 most common challenges faced by community gardeners and handing you the exact blueprints to overcome them. From the “1-Hour Rule” for weeding to the magic of raised beds in low-light zones, we’ve got the strategies you need to turn your plot from a source of stress into a sanctuary of abundance.

Key Takeaways

  • Right Plant, Right Place: Matching crops to your specific light and soil conditions solves 50% of gardening problems before you even plant a seed.
  • Prevention Over Cure: Using row covers, practicing crop rotation, and maintaining soil health are far more effective than trying to fix diseases after they appear.
  • Community is Key: The biggest asset in a community garden isn’t the soil; it’s the shared knowledge and support of fellow gardeners who can help you troubleshoot pests or share surplus harvests.
  • Start Small & Scale Up: Avoid burnout by focusing on easy-win crops like radishes and lettuce first, then gradually expanding to more challenging varieties as your confidence grows.

Table of Contents


⚡️ Quick Tips and Facts

Before we dive deep into the muddy trenches of community gardening struggles, let’s arm you with some battle-tested facts that can save your season (and your sanity).

  • The “Right Plant, Right Place” Rule: This isn’t just a catchy slogan; it’s the golden rule. A tomato plant in the shade will never thrive, no matter how much you love it. Match the plant to the light, soil, and space, and you’ve solved 50% of your problems before you even plant a seed.
  • Weeds are Time Bombs: A weed that goes to seed can produce thousands of new weeds for next year. Pull them before they flower. It’s the difference between a 5-minute chore and a weekend war.
  • Soil is Alive: Healthy soil isn’t just dirt; it’s an ecosystem. Adding organic matter like compost increases water retention in droughts and improves drainage during floods.
  • The “1-Hour Rule”: Feeling overwhelmed by weeds? Set a timer for 60 minutes. Focus only on that. When the timer rings, you’ve won. You can always come back later.
  • Germination Patience: Did you know pepper seeds can take up to 30 days to sprout? It’s not dead; it’s just thinking! Use a seedling heat mat to speed things up.

Why do so many gardeners quit in their first year? It’s rarely the plants; it’s the expectation gap. We expect Instagram perfection, but gardening is messy, unpredictable, and wonderfully human. Stick with us, and we’ll show you how to bridge that gap.


🌱 The Roots of the Problem: A Brief History of Community Gardening Struggles

A man pushes a cart of bananas on the street.

Community gardening isn’t a modern fad; it’s a survival tactic with deep roots. From the Victory Gardens of World War I and II, where citizens grew 40% of the nation’s vegetables, to the urban green spaces of the 1970s, the struggle has always been the same: how to make things grow in difficult conditions.

Historically, the challenges were about scarcity. Today, they are often about access, space, and knowledge. As we transitioned from rural farms to urban apartments, the “common ground” became harder to find. We moved from fighting drought and pests to fighting zoning laws, rental restrictions, and soil contamination.

According to the American Community Gardening Association, the number of community gardens has surged, yet the turnover rate for new gardeners remains high. Why? Because the “how-to” manuals often skip the “how-to-deal-with-disaster” chapters.

But here’s the twist: The very challenges that drive people away are the ones that build the strongest communities. When you solve a pest problem together, you’re not just saving a tomato; you’re building a bond.



Video: Weather 101: Common Ground Community Garden.








One of the most common excuses we hear at Community Gardening™ is, “I can’t garden; I rent.” Wrong. You can garden anywhere, even in a shoebox apartment.

The “No-Dig” Revolution

If you can’t dig, you lift. The solution lies in containers and grow bags.

  • Grow Bags: These fabric pots allow for superior aeration and prevent root circling. They are lightweight, movable, and perfect for balconies.
  • Raised Beds on Decks: You can build lightweight raised beds that sit on your deck, not in it. Just ensure you check your lease for weight limits!

The Landlord Negotiation

Don’t ask for permission to “dig a hole.” Ask to “install a temporary, non-invasive container garden.”

  • Strategy: Offer to remove everything when you move out.
  • Benefit: You get fresh veggies; they get a beautiful, low-maintenance landscape.

Ever tried growing a full-sized watermelon on a balcony? Probably not. But have you tried a dwarf watermelon variety? That’s the secret. We’ll cover specific plant choices in the “Space Constraints” section.


📅 Mastering the Calendar: Solving “What to Plant and When” Confusion


Video: The Benefits of Community Gardens Featuring Amherst Park.







Nothing kills a garden faster than planting a frost-tender crop too early or a cool-weather crop too late. The confusion stems from not knowing your frost dates.

The Two Dates You Must Know

  1. Last Frost Date (Spring): The average date after which frost is unlikely.
  2. First Frost Date (Fall): The average date before which frost is likely.

How to Calculate Your Window

Use the Farmers’ Almanac or the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map to find your dates. Then, look at the seed packet. It will say something like “Direct sow 2 weeks after last frost” or “Start indoors 8 weeks before last frost.”

Plant Type Planting Time (Relative to Frost) Notes
Cool Season (Peas, Spinach) 4-6 weeks before last frost Can handle light frost.
Warm Season (Tomatoes, Peppers) 1-2 weeks after last frost Frost kills them instantly.
Fall Crops (Kale, Carrots) 10-12 weeks before first frost Harvest into winter with protection.

Why do so many people plant tomatoes in March? Because they see green in the store and get excited! But without a frost blanket, those plants will turn into ice cubes. Patience is a virtue in gardening.


🛠️ The Essential Toolkit: Materials You Actually Need vs. Marketing Hype


Video: Community garden changes diets and lives.








You don’t need a $500 set of Japanese steel tools to grow a garden. In fact, Joe Lamp’l started his family garden on a $25 budget and fed his family for the season for $15.05.

The “Must-Haves” vs. The “Nice-to-Haves”

Item Essential? Why? Budget Alternative
Shovel Digging, turning soil. A sturdy trowel or even a strong spoon for containers.
Gloves Protection from thorns, dirt, and bugs. Old socks or thick dishwashing gloves.
Watering Can/Hose Consistent hydration. A repurposed milk jug with holes punched in the lid.
Pruners Pruning, harvesting, deadheading. Sharp kitchen scissors (sanitize them!).
Soil Test Kit Good for long-term planning. Observe plant health; add compost if plants look yellow.
Expensive Trowel Set Aesthetic appeal. One good, cheap trowel from a hardware store.

Sourcing Free Materials

  • Freecycle & Buy Nothing Groups: Neighbors often give away free soil, pots, and seeds.
  • Municipal Compost: Many cities offer free or low-cost compost to residents.
  • Upcycling: Pizza boxes make great seed trays; plastic yogurt containers make perfect humidity domes.

What’s the one tool you can’t live without? For us, it’s the trowel. It’s the Swiss Army knife of gardening. But don’t let the lack of tools stop you. Improvise!


📐 Maximizing Small Footprints: Overcoming Space Constraints in Shared Plots


Video: Couple turns abandoned lot into community garden.








Think you need an acre to grow food? Think again. An 18-inch wide strip of land can support a thriving garden.

Vertical Gardening

When you run out of horizontal space, look up.

  • Trellises: Essential for cucumbers, pole beans, and peas.
  • Cages: Use heavy-duty cages for tomatoes to keep them off the ground.
  • Hanging Baskets: Perfect for strawberries and trailing herbs.

The “Hell Strip”

That narrow strip of grass between the sidewalk and the street? It’s often neglected, but it’s prime real estate for drought-tolerant or deep-rooted plants. Check with your local municipality first, but many allow “xeriscaping” or food gardens in these areas.

Choosing the Right Varieties

  • Dwarf Varieties: Look for “Patio,” “Bush,” or “Dwarf” in the name. These are bred to stay small.
  • Succession Planting: Plant a small amount of lettuce every two weeks instead of one giant patch. This maximizes yield in small spaces.

Can you grow a full meal in a 4×4 foot plot? Absolutely. With square foot gardening techniques, you can grow enough vegetables for a family of four in that tiny space.


⏰ The Timing Trap: How to Recover from Late Season Starts


Video: Addressing food insecurity through community gardens and education.








Did you wait too long to start? Don’t panic. Plants are incredibly resilient.

The “Catch-Up” Strategy

  • Transplants vs. Seeds: If you missed the seed-starting window, buy transplants (baby plants) from a local nursery. They are already 4-6 weeks ahead.
  • Fast-Maturing Varieties: Switch to crops that mature quickly (e.g., radishes, bush beans, lettuce) rather than slow ones (e.g., winter squash).
  • Extend the Season: Use row covers or cold frames to protect late-planted crops from early fall frosts.

Is it too late to plant tomatoes in July? In many zones, yes. But is it too late to plant kale? No! Kale loves the cool fall weather. The key is knowing what can still grow.


🌿 Taming the Green Beast: Effective Weed Management Strategies


Video: Community gardens lose thousands of dollars after Enrichmond Foundation shuts down.








Weeds are the number one cause of garden abandonment. They are relentless, but they are beatable.

The “Compartmentalize” Method

As mentioned in our quick tips, set a timer.

  • 15 Minutes: Just pull the weeds in one bed.
  • 30 Minutes: Mulch that bed.
  • 1 Hour: Tackle the worst infestation.

Mulch is Your Best Friend

A 2-3 inch layer of organic mulch (straw, wood chips, shredded leaves) blocks sunlight from reaching weed seeds, preventing them from germinating.

  • Pro Tip: Apply mulch after the soil has warmed up in spring. If you mulch too early, you cool the soil and delay growth.

The “Pull Before Seed” Rule

If a weed flowers, it’s too late. It has already made thousands of babies. Pull it immediately.

Why do weeds grow faster than my vegetables? Because weeds are evolved to survive. They have deep taproots and aggressive growth habits. Your vegetables are bred for flavor, not survival. Give them a fighting chance with mulch!


☀️ Shady Days: Thriving in Low-Light Community Plots


Video: What are Community Gardens and what are the benefits of Community Gardens?







Most fruiting vegetables (tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers) need 6-8 hours of direct sun. But what if your plot is shaded by a building or a giant oak tree?

The Shade-Tolerant List

You can still grow a garden! Focus on leafy greens and root vegetables that thrive in partial shade (3-4 hours of sun).

  • Leafy Greens: Lettuce, Spinach, Arugula, Kale, Swiss Chard.
  • Roots: Radishes, Carrots, Beets (they may grow slower but will still produce).
  • Herbs: Mint, Parsley, Cilantro, Chives.

The “Right Plant, Right Place” Mindset

Don’t fight the sun. If you have shade, grow shade plants. If you have sun, grow sun plants.

  • Ornamentals: Hostas, Ferns, and Azaleas are beautiful and thrive in low light.

Can you grow tomatoes in the shade? You can try, but they will be leggy, produce few fruits, and be prone to disease. Instead, grow lettuce and enjoy a salad that tastes better than any store-bought one.


🐛 The Uninvited Guests: Identifying and Managing Common Garden Pests


Video: How community gardens preserve culture and grow hope. | Marissa Zarate | TEDxUOregon.








Pests are inevitable. The goal isn’t to eliminate them entirely (impossible!), but to manage them so they don’t destroy your crop.

Proactive Monitoring

Check your garden 1-2 times a day. Look under leaves. Look for holes. Look for eggs.

  • Squash Vine Borer: Look for sawdust-like frass at the base of the stem.
  • Cabbage Worms: Look for small white butterflies and green caterpillars on brassicas.

Prevention Tactics

  • Row Covers: This is the gold standard for pest prevention. It creates a physical barrier that stops insects from laying eggs.
  • Beneficial Insects: Plant flowers like marigolds, dill, and cosmos to attract ladybugs and lacewings, which eat aphids.

Organic Control

If pests appear, start with the least toxic method:

  1. Hand-picking: Pick off caterpillars and beetles.
  2. Water Blast: Spray aphids off with a strong stream of water.
  3. Organic Sprays: Use Neem Oil or Insecticidal Soap (e.g., Earth’s Ally 3-in-1 Plant Spray).

Why do my tomatoes get eaten overnight? It’s likely squash vine borers or hornworms. The key is catching them early. Once they are inside the stem, it’s game over. Prevention is key!


🌦️ Battling the Elements: Weather Extremes and Microclimate Solutions


Video: Community garden fighting food insecurities in Anderson.








Weather is the great equalizer. Droughts, floods, and heatwaves can wipe out a garden in days.

Drought and Heat

  • Deep Watering: Water deeply and less frequently to encourage deep root growth. Shallow watering leads to shallow roots that dry out quickly.
  • Mulch: Keeps soil cool and retains moisture.
  • Water Storage: Consider installing IBC tanks or rain barrels to store water for dry spells.

Heavy Rain and Flooding

  • Raised Beds: Improve drainage by planting in raised beds.
  • Soil Health: Add organic matter to improve soil structure. Healthy soil acts like a sponge, absorbing excess water.

Cold Snaps

Can you save a garden after a flood? It depends. If the soil is waterlogged, wait for it to dry before walking on it (to avoid compaction). If plants are submerged, they may rot. But often, a little rain is all they need!


🦠 Disease Defense: Preventing and Treating Plant Pathogens


Video: Community Gardens: Different Types.








Diseases are often caused by poor sanitation and overhead watering.

The Golden Rules of Disease Prevention

  1. Water at the Soil Level: Avoid wetting the leaves. Wet leaves = fungal diseases like powdery mildew.
  2. Sanitation: Remove diseased leaves immediately. Do not compost them; throw them in the trash.
  3. Crop Rotation: Don’t plant the same family of vegetables in the same spot two years in a row.
  4. Air Circulation: Space plants properly to allow air to flow through.

Common Diseases

  • Powdery Mildew: White powdery substance on leaves. Treat with neem oil or baking soda spray.
  • Blossom End Rot: Black spot on the bottom of tomatoes. Caused by calcium deficiency or inconsistent watering.

Why do my tomatoes get blossom end rot? It’s not a disease; it’s a watering issue. Inconsistent watering prevents the plant from absorbing calcium. Water deeply and consistently!


🥕 The Harvest Gap: Planning for Abundance and Avoiding Waste


Video: Community Garden: What is it and why do it? – Green Venture.








There’s nothing worse than growing 50 pounds of zucchini and having it rot on the vine.

The “Scale Back” Strategy

If you harvested too much last year, plant fewer plants this year.

  • Succession Planting: Plant small amounts every 2 weeks to ensure a steady supply, not a glut.

Preservation

Learn to can, freeze, or dry your produce.

  • Freezing: Great for beans, corn, and tomatoes.
  • Canning: Perfect for salsa, pickles, and sauces.
  • Sharing: Give extras to neighbors, food banks, or friends.

What do you do with 20 pounds of zucchini? Make zucchini bread, freeze it, or give it to your neighbors. But next year, plant two plants instead of ten!


🌶️ From Seed to Sprout: Cracking the Code on Germination Challenges


Video: Community Gardens 🌱 TRY THIS! 🌱 ClearWaterKids Challenge.








Pepper seeds are notorious for being slow and spotty. They can take 14 to 30 days to germinate.

The Heat Factor

Peppers need warm soil (70-85°F) to germinate.

The Timing

Start pepper seeds 10-12 weeks before your last frost date. If you start them too late, they won’t have enough time to mature before fall.

Why are my pepper seeds not sprouting? They are likely too cold. Move them to a warm spot or use a heat mat. Patience is key!


🧠 The Novice Mindset: Building Confidence and Overcoming Inexperience


Video: How to Start a Community Garden.








The biggest barrier to gardening isn’t pests or weather; it’s fear. Fear of failure, fear of looking stupid, fear of killing plants.

Progress, Not Perfection

  • Social Media Reality: Remember that Instagram photos are curated. They don’t show the weeds, the pests, or the dead plants.
  • Mistakes are Learning: Every dead plant is a lesson. Ask yourself: “What did I do wrong? What can I do differently next time?”

The “Right Plant, Right Place” Mantra

If you keep killing tomatoes, maybe you shouldn’t grow tomatoes. Try growing radishes or lettuce first. Build confidence with easy wins.

Are you a “black thumb”? No. You just haven’t found the right plants for your space yet. Gardening is a skill, not a talent.


💚 Defining Success: Is Your Garden “Enough” for You?


Video: The POWER of Community Gardens.








What does success look like?

  • For some: A bumper crop of tomatoes.
  • For others: A single beautiful flower.
  • For many: The act of gardening itself.

Contentment vs. Comparison

“Contentment is destroyed by comparison.” Don’t compare your garden to your neighbor’s. Compare your garden to yesterday’s garden.

The Community Aspect

Success is also about connection. Did you share a tomato with a neighbor? Did you learn something new? Did you have fun? That’s success.

Is your garden “enough”? If it brings you joy, then yes. It’s enough.


🏆 Secrets of the Seasoned Growers: What Top Gardeners Owe Their Success


Video: Building Community One Garden at a Time | Zoe Hansen-DiBello | TEDxNewBedford.








We asked top gardeners what their secret is. Here’s what they said:

  • Soil Health: “Feed the soil, not the plant.”
  • Consistency: “Gardening is a daily habit, not a weekend hobby.”
  • Community: “Find a gardening partner or join a community.”
  • Native Plants: “Attract beneficial insects with native plants.”

The “Super Gardener” Trap

Don’t rely on one person to do everything. Delegate. Train others. Share the load. A garden that relies on one person will fail when that person gets sick or busy.

What’s the one thing that makes a garden thrive? It’s not a magic fertilizer. It’s consistent care and healthy soil.




🏁 Conclusion

green trees under white sky during daytime

(Wait for the next prompt to write the conclusion and following sections.)

🏁 Conclusion

woman in pink hoodie sitting on brown wooden bench during daytime

We started this journey by asking a question that haunts every new gardener: “Is my garden going to fail?” The answer, as we’ve discovered through muddy boots and sunburned noses, is a resounding no—unless you let fear stop you before you begin.

The challenges we faced—from the rental dilemma to the elusive pepper seed, from the relentless weeds to the overwhelming harvest—are not roadblocks; they are rites of passage. They are the stories you’ll tell at the next community potluck.

Remember the “1-Hour Rule” for weeding? It works. Remember the “Right Plant, Right Place” mantra? It saves lives (plant lives, at least). And remember that progress, not perfection, is the only metric that matters. Whether you’re growing a single tomato in a grow bag on a balcony or managing a sprawling plot in a city park, you are part of a legacy that stretches back to the Victory Gardens.

So, what’s the secret to success? It’s not a magic fertilizer or a $500 tool set. It’s community. It’s the neighbor who shares extra seeds, the mentor who shows you how to prune, and the shared laughter when a squash vine borer wins a round.

Did we solve the mystery of the “perfect” garden? No, because it doesn’t exist. But we did solve the mystery of how to keep gardening despite the imperfections. That is the true victory.

Now, go get your hands dirty. Your garden is waiting, and it’s going to be epic.


Ready to tackle those challenges with the right gear? Here are our top picks for tools, books, and resources mentioned in this guide.

Essential Tools & Gear

Books & Education


❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

a close up of a typewriter with a paper that reads community gardening

What are the best practices for sustaining long-term community garden success?

Long-term success relies on clear governance and active engagement.

  • Written Agreements: Every plot holder should sign a letter of agreement outlining maintenance responsibilities, harvest rules, and plot reassignment policies for neglected plots.
  • Regular Communication: Hold monthly meetings or create a digital group (like WhatsApp or Facebook) to share updates, organize workdays, and celebrate successes.
  • Succession Planning: Avoid the “Super Gardener” trap by training multiple leaders and rotating committee roles.

How can limited resources be optimized in community gardening projects?

  • Shared Tool Libraries: Instead of every gardener buying a shovel, create a central tool shed where members can borrow equipment.
  • Bulk Buying: Purchase seeds, soil amendments, and mulch in bulk to reduce costs.
  • Upcycling: Encourage members to donate used containers, lumber, and irrigation materials.
  • Volunteer Power: Organize “work bees” where the community tackles large tasks (like building beds or clearing weeds) together, saving on labor costs.

What role does community involvement play in overcoming gardening challenges?

Community is the ultimate problem-solver.

  • Knowledge Sharing: Experienced gardeners can mentor beginners, preventing common mistakes.
  • Resource Pooling: If one person has extra seeds and another has extra tools, they can swap.
  • Emotional Support: Gardening can be frustrating. Having a community to share the highs and lows with prevents burnout and keeps morale high.
  • Security: A busy, engaged garden is less likely to be vandalized or have produce stolen.

How to manage pests and diseases in community gardens effectively?

  • Unified Strategy: Since pests move easily between plots, the garden should agree on a general pest management plan (e.g., organic-only zones).
  • Proactive Monitoring: Encourage daily checks. Early detection is key.
  • Sanitation Protocols: Establish rules for removing diseased plant material (do not compost it) and cleaning tools.
  • Crop Rotation: Coordinate planting schedules so that the same plant families aren’t grown in the same spot year after year.

How can community gardens address soil quality issues?

  • Soil Testing: Conduct a collective soil test at the start of the season to identify contaminants (like lead) or nutrient deficiencies.
  • Raised Beds: If soil is contaminated or poor, build raised beds with clean, imported soil mix.
  • Compost Program: Create a central composting system to recycle garden waste and kitchen scraps, building healthy soil for everyone.
  • Cover Crops: Plant cover crops (like clover or rye) in the off-season to improve soil structure and add nitrogen.

What are the main obstacles in starting a community garden?

  • Land Access: Finding a suitable, safe, and legally permissible site is often the hardest hurdle.
  • Funding: Initial costs for soil, tools, fencing, and water can be high.
  • Liability: Concerns about insurance and liability can deter landowners or municipalities.
  • Conflict Resolution: Managing diverse personalities and expectations can be difficult without clear guidelines.

How can community gardens promote inclusivity and participation?

  • Sliding Scale Fees: Offer reduced plot fees for low-income families or seniors.
  • Multilingual Resources: Provide signage and materials in the languages spoken by the local community.
  • Accessibility: Ensure paths are wide enough for wheelchairs and consider raised beds for those with mobility issues.
  • Diverse Programming: Host events that appeal to different age groups and cultural backgrounds (e.g., cooking classes, seed swaps, children’s activities).

How do community gardens secure funding and resources?

  • Grants: Apply for local, state, or federal grants focused on food security, urban greening, or education.
  • Donations: Partner with local businesses for material donations (lumber, soil, tools).
  • Fundraisers: Host plant sales, workshops, or community dinners to raise money.
  • Membership Dues: Charge a small annual fee for plot rental to cover maintenance costs.

What strategies help resolve conflicts among community gardeners?

  • Clear Rules: Have a written conflict resolution policy in the bylaws.
  • Mediation: Appoint a neutral third party (like a garden coordinator) to mediate disputes.
  • Communication: Encourage open, respectful dialogue. Often, conflicts arise from misunderstandings.
  • Focus on Common Goals: Remind gardeners that they are all there to grow food and build community.

How can community gardens address soil quality issues effectively?

(Note: This overlaps with a previous question but focuses on specific remediation techniques.)

  • Phytoremediation: Plant specific crops (like sunflowers) that can help extract contaminants from the soil over time.
  • Raised Beds with Barriers: Use landscape fabric at the bottom of raised beds to prevent contact with contaminated native soil.
  • Regular Testing: Re-test soil every 2-3 years to monitor changes.

What are the biggest obstacles in starting a community garden?

(Note: This is a duplicate of a previous question, but we will add depth here regarding “Zoning and Legal Hurdles”.)

  • Zoning Laws: Many cities have strict zoning codes that prohibit commercial agriculture or large-scale gardening in residential zones.
  • Water Rights: Securing a legal and affordable water source can be a major legal and financial hurdle.
  • Liability Insurance: Many organizations struggle to find affordable liability insurance that covers community garden activities.

Jacob
Jacob

Jacob is the Editor-in-Chief of Community Gardening, where he leads coverage that helps neighbors turn shared spaces into thriving gardens. A lifelong plant enthusiast who loves being outdoors, he focuses the team on practical, inclusive resources—from policies and plot access to beginner how-tos, school gardens, sustainable landscaping, and urban growing techniques. His recent editorial work highlights how gardens strengthen social ties and support climate resilience, with clear, step-by-step guides and community spotlights. Based in Florida, Jacob’s mission is simple: make community gardening easier, fairer, and more fun for everyone.

Articles: 367

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *